The Best and the Brightest is considered by many to be the definitive book explaining how the United States got involved in the Vietnam War and why we found it so difficult to extract ourselves once it became evident we were fighting a losing battle. Published in 1972, David Halberstam does a masterful job of introducing a lengthy list of key players on the American side, along with their past histories and motivations. While many of the people highlighted will not be familiar to a younger audience, for anyone who grew up in the 1960s, they are remembered all too well. His cast of characters include Presidents John F. Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson, Robert McNamara, and General William Westmoreland. But just as important, and maybe even more so, are the highly educated government officials who served under both presidents, referred to at the time as the country’s best and brightest.
A major driving factor leading to our involvement goes back to the Communists’ taking control of China in 1949, while the Democrats were in power in the U.S. This segued to the Republicans taking over the White House in the 1950s and the rise of Red Scare McCarthyism during the 1950s. After the Democrats regained power in 1960, they were determined not to be shackled with the blame should Vietnam follow China and go Communist as well. But just as important was the hubris of the government officials under Kennedy and LBJ. Despite a wealth of evidence suggesting otherwise, it was believed that, once we were involved militarily, victory was assured because of our superiority in weapons and manpower. What they failed to realize or admit was that the conflict had little to do with the spread of Communism and more to do with local Vietnamese nationalists seeking to reunite their country.
Clearly highlighted in the book is how we tiptoed, piecemeal, into the conflict, first with advisors, then with a steady influx of American soldiers. At each step along the way, it was thought that we could easily back out, not understanding that once our troops were on the ground, we’d stepped into a quagmire that would require continued escalation simply to save face. One would like to believe that the lessons from the Vietnam War would prevent our country from making similar mistakes in the future. Yet in reading this book today, the parallels with our recent involvement in Afghanistan are striking. While The Best and the Brightest, with its 688 pages in small type, is by no means an easy read, it is a study that remains just as relevant now as when it was first published.