Published in 2006, The Echo Maker opens late one winter evening when Mark Schluter’s truck overturns on a lonely highway in the flatlands of Nebraska. Pulled from the vehicle, he is rushed to a hospital where he remains in a coma for an extended period of time. His sister Karen quits her job in a distant city and returns to their hometown to be by his side. When Mark does wake from his coma, he discovers an anonymous note by his bedside that reads in part, “God lead me to you so you could live.” While he cannot remember the details of the crash, there are skid marks at the accident sight indicating he was trying to avoid hitting something or someone. And the police have no idea who called 911 to report the crash. It has all the markings of a clever mystery story waiting to be solved.
To complicate matters, when Mark finally awakens, his head trauma has caused another problem; he is suffering from Capgras syndrome. It is a condition that prevents a person from recalling intense emotional situations. In this case, Mark believes his sister (and his dog, too) is an imposter, an actress hired to take her place. This opening setup had me curiously hooked from the get go. Throw in a neuroscientist who is a dead ringer for Oliver Sacks, an environmentalist battling to save the sandhill cranes that migrate through the area every spring, and there is plenty of material to chew on in this novel.
And yet with such a great premise, I never warmed to Powers’ prose or to the characters he so intricately created on the page. There was something clinical and distant in his presentation. The book won the National Book Award following its publication, leading me to believe that Powers is a writer who either wows a reader or leaves them cold. Unfortunately, for this novel at least, I fall into the second camp. By the time the author tied up the separate plot lines at the story’s end, I had already lost interest.